Stephane Dion’s Much Ado About Carbon
June 18, 2008 · By Matthew
If the quote-unquote party insiders that have been talking to the Globe and Mail are to be believed, then tomorrow’s announcement by Liberal Party leader Stephane Dion will almost certainly confirm that the NDP is going to rival its 1984 record seat count and the Conservatives are heading for a nice, cushy majority government soon. Think of it this way, the carbon “shift” won’t tax gas users, tax low-income Canadians or tax Canadians who depend on fuel for their livelihood (something Big Oil TM can argue a strong case about, by the way!). Consider as well that Dion is going out of his way to assure us that the tax cuts (a measly 10%, max, when you consider how this is going to hurt our economy) that he is proposing to offset the carbon tax are going to monitored for their parity day and night.
What we have after all those caveats is a shift that won’t do an iota to change the habits of Canadians, if the goal is still, in fact, to save ourselves from the sixth element of the periodic table. The fact that Dion is trying to convince us that life will go on normally also demonstrates that the professor didn’t take much chemistry in his undergrad as even the only item that doesn’t require carbon for production, computer software, still requires a bunch of energy that comes from carbon just to run the computers that make the programs. How is this not going to affect us?
Then, of course, we must consider what corporations are going to do. Being nobody’s fool, any industry that pollutes like the steel factories in Hamilton, the auto plants in the GTA or the oil refineries in Alberta, will just find a way to slip their sites south of the border where the environmental lunacy currently hasn’t hit the same heights. Under Stephane Dion’s loophole-ridden Canada, we sell our oil assets to the States, sacrifice jobs that would’ve been created to refine the black gold, then buy it back at a loss for our vehicles that aren’t going anywhere because of said lack of jobs.
So, with that all considered, can we really count on the Liberals to actually follow through with anything? Well, they’re still proposing a tax aren’t they? And since I just spent three paragraphs explaining the glories of this plan, and that your average Canadian voter stops reading after “insiders”, I’d say that Stephane Dion will successfully reduce our carbon pollution by putting the massive CO2 emitters currently in the Liberal caucus out on the street, and ensuring that their successors won’t be blowing so much hot air about a plan too gentle for environmentalists, too harmful for conservatives and too complex for a national party to win voters over on!


So what happens if his plan actually works and reduces our use of carbon based energy? How will he compensate for the reduced tax revenue? Will he continue to raise the per ton carbon tax or will he begin to raise corporate and personal income taxes? Too bad the MSM will never ask those questions…
I wish I were as confident as you Matthew that Canadian voters will toss step-on Dion out on his ass in an election. Great blog Matthew but will your common sense message get out to the Canadian public who are drowning in a sea of fake, global warming BS, spoonfed to them by every type of media? The same media giving us headlines that focus only on the 10% tax cuts with step-on’s pictures below it? That is the point at which people stop reading and start thinking “gee, this step-on dude is pretty cool”.
I definately appreciate your insight glacialgal, and I don’t think you would mind if I say that I hope that I’ve got a better scope on this one! All I can add is that I am banking on your average Ontarian/Quebecer being constantly reminded every time they walk/drive by a gas station why we shouldn’t be trusting a politician to exempt gas from a carbon tax, which would lead into a “what’s the point” mentality, and thus give the Conservatives a chance for their own Hidden Agenda TM attack ads. Only time will tell. Cheers!