A new poll conducted by COMPAS Research for the Financial Post shows that Canada’s business community believes that separatist support in the province may be on the rise.
This week’s web poll of Canadian CEO’s and business leaders indicates that there is growing concern that high oil prices and Alberta’s growing economic strength may foster further divisions within Confederation:
According to most respondents, a major fallout from Alberta’s petrol wealth will be increased conflict between Edmonton and Ottawa… The panel as a whole assigns a 70% probability to this taking place. The panel assigns an approximately 50% probability to
- Alberta’s becoming more influential,
- An Alberta separatist party surpassing 20% in provincial polls,
and- Several large financial institutions moving to Calgary.
Respondents are not quite convinced that Calgary will surpass Toronto in the number of head offices its hosts. Yet, the panel assigns an average probability of 41% to this happening- a probability of less than 50% and yet sizeable nonetheless.
The poll also asked respondents on a 100 percentage point probability scale ( zero meaning “it definitely won’t happen”, and 100 meaning “that it will almost certainly happen”) to score the likelihood of a number of Canadian scenarios occurring within the next decade. Those polled assigned a mean score of 70 to the likelihood that “conflict intensifies between Alberta and central Canada”. Alberta becoming Canada’s most influential province scored a 51, and “An Alberta separatist party gets 20% of the vote in a provincial election” scored a 49. Significantly, those surveyed thought it was more likely that separatism would take off in Alberta (49) than having an Albertan-led Conservative Party form the government (44). The following responses from two of those surveyed may give us an indication as to why this is the case.
- By an Alberta leader of the Conservatives, if you are referring to
Stephen Harper, it won’t happen. He may be a great guy, but he
lacks charisma and warmth, and the remake is making things worse.
It highlights his discomfort with being Mr Congeniality. - Alberta definitely has the winds at its back. However, its population is
only a quarter of Ontario, which will limit its influence to some extent.
With attitudes such as this, it seems almost a certainty that those people who run in to a “glass ceiling” attempting to increase Alberta’s influence inside Confederation will look more favorably upon going outside of it as entirely more realistic .
Cross posted to Dispatches From The Western Alien Nation

Speller wrote:
“The likelihood that “conflict intensifies between Alberta and CENTRAL Canadaâ€?.
Wow! Get over yourselves Ontario. You think you’re CENTRAL Canada electing the CENTRIST Liberals?
Talk about selfCENTREDNESS!
Marc Lalonde, the architect of the NEP, said the CENTRAL purpose of the NEP was to keep political influence and prestige from moving to Alberta.
Posted on 31-Jul-05 at 10:55 pm | Permalink
Jeff wrote:
Peter, I’ve written a piece on your banter with JimBobbySez.
Regarding Alberta’s glass ceiling, I feel we (Alberta) need a stronger voice in the halls of Ottawa. Ralph is a good old boy but like a hound dog thats seen his better days go by, I feel Ralph has the same ‘bark but no bite’.
Let’s face it, he’s tired, complacent and SOBER. Give that man the SAUCE again! He was a heck of alot more on his game when he was blitzed…………
Posted on 01-Aug-05 at 5:58 pm | Permalink
Speller wrote:
Ralp Klein has NEVER won a fight with Ottawa. He has the power to win but never uses it. He isn’t facing any more elections so he doesn’t bother putting on the mask.
If Mr. Klein ever pretends to fight again, it will only be to stampede the Ontario voters toward the Liberals in a federal election. Just like last time.
I’m not voting PC ever again. Step up, potential Fathers of a New Nation. Win my VOTE!
Posted on 01-Aug-05 at 9:15 pm | Permalink