Anti-Western Bigotry Comes into the Open at the Globe and Mail

May 23, 2005 · By

To hear what bigots are really thinking, listen to them when they’re talking among themselves.

The Globe’s national columnists and editorialists usually try to keep their anti-Western bigotry under a thin cover. They want you to believe they see Westerners as equal partners in Canada. Of course they don’t believe a word of it, but they want their product to sell across the country.

But when they write columns intended only for fellow Ontarians, they say what they’re really thinking.

John Barber is the Globe’s Toronto columnist. Unlike their national writers, he doesn’t even bother to hide his contempt for the West.

Here’s the headline from his latest column, on the fortunes of the federal Conservatives in Ontario:

The Mask Slips on this Crop of Prairie Preachers

Rarely have Ontarians’ real views been expressed so openly: Westerners are nothing but foreigners who don’t really belong at the center of things.

That’s exactly how Barber puts it:

To be an Ontarian through every stage of the Alberta crusade is to understand what it must have been like for the original inhabitants of these shores to encounter the Récollet “Black Robes” more than 300 years ago. Their arrogance was so stunning as to be almost quaint.

That’s right. That’s what Ontarians really think of the West. It’s what they say when they’re talking to themselves.

To Ontarians, Westerners are nothing but unwelcome foreign invaders, a bunch of visiting missionaries with alien beliefs. So goes the stereotype from Ontario. So goes its anti-Western bigotry.

The column is a hatchet review of Westerners’ attempts to be heard in Ontario. It’s all been a waste of time, concludes the Globe’s Toronto columnist, because Ontario will never vote for the stupid rubes from the West:

Exactly the same thing has already happened four times before to this same group in different guises: in the elections of 1993 and 1997, when urban Ontario first rejected the Reform Party so decisively; in 2000, when it repeated the lesson for the benefit of the Canadian Alliance; and in 2004, when the amalgamated Conservative Party failed again to reoccupy the terrain that once welcomed Brian Mulroney’s Progressive Conservatives.

It’s all been a waste of time, because Ontario will never give up its view of Westerners as stupid foreigners. Writes Barber:

Just as an earlier breed of Prairie evangelists streamed east preaching the social gospel … their legacy will likewise be limited — an undigested lump of regional grievance in the national craw, never a government.

He’s an open bigot, but Barber is right in one sense. It really has been a waste of time. The idea of Canada as an equal partnership is a fraud. The claim that all Canadians are equal is a lie. Ontarians will never see Westerners as equal Canadians.

Comments

7 Responses to “Anti-Western Bigotry Comes into the Open at the Globe and Mail”

  1. Doug on May 23rd, 2005 10:13 am [#]

    As I have told friends, time and time again, when Quebec secedes, politics in Canada will achieve a more equal balance between left and right.

    Take it from an outsider who has moved here. You have to get over this obsession of “national unity” with Quebec. It’s poitless, and as a one way street. I thought you Canadians prided yourselves on being “aware” of world trends. Well, sovereignty based on culture is certainly one trend on which you have your head buried deep in the sand.

    Let them go. It will do everyone good.

  2. Max West on May 23rd, 2005 11:17 am [#]

    You’re right, Doug. It’s surprising how few conservatives have seen that Quebec’s secession would tip the ideological balance in their favour, and not just because we’d get rid of several million lefties. Much of the big-government apparatus of Canada is there only because the fetish called “national unity.”

  3. john on May 23rd, 2005 1:30 pm [#]

    agreed – although i expect some boob from ontario will soon pipe in and tell us we are nuts. since the emergence of the BQ in the early 1990s, there has been a overarching tendency in the ROC to see the bloc as enemies of Canada. the latest liberal talking points, for example, continue to try to taint harper for working with the bloc. i for one would prefer to see them as fellow citizens who also understand the sorry state of Canada. would i be sorry to see them on their way? less sorry than the perpetuation of this moribund sclerocracy we call a country.

  4. Tom Cerber on May 23rd, 2005 4:19 pm [#]

    Wonderful, thanks Max. Sounds like a wonderfully clear statement of Ontarian attitude untainted from contrary politeness and niceties meant to sell papers west of Barrie.

    Harper as a black robe. What a laugh. What’s even more funny is that the movie, “Black Robe,” received a lot of flack for actually portraying the Natives as barbarians. Seems the analogy is more apt than the writer means.

  5. ThePolitic - Canadian Political Weblog » Yet More Anti-Western Bigotry from the Globe and Mail on June 3rd, 2005 6:37 pm [#]

    [...]
    There they go again. Yet another smug Ontarian smirking from [...]

  6. ThePolitic - Canadian Political Weblog » Americans will have a Black President before Ontarians will accept a PM from the West on June 9th, 2005 8:06 am [#]

    [...] pace of Ontario journalists’ anti-Western bigotry by many times before – again and again and again and again. So here [...]

  7. Andrew on June 18th, 2005 4:25 pm [#]

    So Albertans look poorly on Ontarians too?

Got something to say? (Read the rules first)